Cobalt LogotypeWhite

Autonomous Pentesting
Pulse Report

Where the line between human expertise and AI now sits, and what’s moving it.

94% vs. 2%

Buyers who say agentic AI will be critical or very important to their offensive security within two years, [1] versus pentesters who would trust current AI to chain a known exploit into a multi-step attack without supervision.

64% → 26%

Pentesters ranking autonomous scanning the least effective testing model, January vs. September 2026 (down 38 percentage points).

61%

Pentesters who now use AI frequently or extensively, up from 32% in January (up 29 percentage points).

Omdia buyer survey, March 2026, n=400. Cobalt Core pentester surveys, January 2026 (n=198) and September 2026 (n=94). Omdia results are not an endorsement of Cobalt.
autonomous-pulse-report_cover-tn2

Hybrid is the working model:

AI for speed and breadth,
experts for depth and judgment

Buyers expect agentic AI to reshape offensive security within two years, yet only 7% run AI agents at full autonomy today. [2] And while pentesters doing the work already rely on AI heavily, they still won't let it run alone. That gap between what buyers forecast and what practitioners trust is where your next budget decision sits.

The Autonomous Pentesting Pulse Report pairs Omdia buyer research with two surveys of the Cobalt Core, our community of 500+ vetted pentesters, taken nine months apart. It shows where AI can safely take on work now, what it costs as testing goes deeper, and how to verify what an autonomous system actually tested.

Built for the people who make the call and the people who inform it

Security and technology leaders: A clear view of where autonomous testing fits in your program and where human-led testing still has to carry the weight.

Budget owners: The cost curve behind AI-delivered testing, and the questions to ask any vendor before you fund it.

AppSec and security practitioners: First-hand data from surveys of working pentesters on what AI now does well and what they still do themselves.

autonomous-pulse-report-spread-tn
Recommendations

Six decisionsto make before your next budget cycle

The boundary between human-led and autonomous testing moved in nine months. These steps help you capture AI’s gains without overextending.

1

Put AI to work where it's proven
Recon, data analysis, reporting, and increasingly exploit development have shifted to AI. Expect your testers and vendors to use it there.

2

Keep expert oversight where AI can't verify its own work
Business logic, authorization, and multi-step attack chains still need qualified human judgment.

3

Ask for evidence of coverage from every testing model
Ask who reviews AI output, how run-to-run variation is handled, and how the vendor shows what was tested.

4

Match the testing model and the budget to the depth you need
Autonomous testing suits shallow, high-frequency coverage. Deep testing of critical assets still calls for human-led work.

5

Choose partners who invest in AI where it counts
Look for measurable improvement in testing, not only marketing claims.

6

Revisit the boundary often
Reassess where AI fits in your program at least twice a year.

Inside a pentest:
Where AI has moved in, and where it hasn't

We asked Cobalt Core pentesters which parts of a pentest have shifted significantly from manual effort to AI.
The answer depends on the task: some work has largely moved to AI, while the tasks that call for context and judgment are still led by people.

Click or tap any bar in the chart to see how far AI has moved into that task and what still needs a human.

Share of pentesters who say each task has shifted significantly to AI, September 2026

Shifted to AI: share of pentesters saying each task has shifted significantly from manual effort to AI-assisted or AI-automated in the past 6 to 12 months (select all that apply). Source: Cobalt Core pentester surveys, September 2026 (n=94) and January 2026 (n=198). "Most valuable use" figures are pentesters who use AI (September n=92; January n=192). The figure for where pentesters still focus manual effort comes from an open-ended question, with answers grouped by theme (70 answered). [2]

Five tasks, five different answers

Click or tap a bar in the chart to explore that task. Click or tap it again to clear your selection.

See where the line between human-led and AI pentesting sits today, and what is moving it.

Download the report
FAQ
What is the Autonomous Pentesting Pulse Report?
A Cobalt research report on where AI can safely take on offensive security work today, where human expertise still leads, and what that means for security budgets and vendor selection. It combines buyer research from Omdia with two surveys of the Cobalt Core, Cobalt's community of 500 vetted pentesters.
Where does the data come from?
  • Omdia buyer survey:400 North American IT and cybersecurity professionals responsible for offensive security strategy, surveyed March 9 to 13, 2026. The research was commissioned by Cobalt.
  • Cobalt Core pentester surveys:198 pentesters surveyed from December 2025 to January 2026, and 94 surveyed September 14 to 21, 2026. Smaller samples mean changes of a few points should be read as directional.
  • Cobalt State of Pentesting Report 2026: A survey of security leaders and practitioners, referenced for AI readiness findings.
What is the difference between automated, autonomous, and agentic testing?

They are not the same thing. In this report, autonomous testing means AI that plans, executes, and reports on testing without a human tester directing each step. The report recommends asking every vendor what their term means and how they show what was tested.

Does the report say AI will replace pentesters?
No. Nearly all pentesters still rank at least one human-led model ahead of autonomous scanning, and PTaaS remains the model they rank most effective. The report makes the case for a hybrid program: autonomous testing for continuous coverage, human-led testing where depth and context matter.
Does the report include recommendations?
Yes. It closes with six recommendations for executives and security leaders on where to apply AI, where to keep expert oversight, and how to hold every testing approach to evidence of coverage.
Who should read it?
CISOs and security leaders setting AI strategy, the finance and technology executives who approve the budget, and the AppSec and security practitioners who will be asked to evaluate vendors.
autonomous-pulse-report_cover-tn2

Before you budget autonomous testing, see what buyers and pentesters actually trust

Sources

1. Source – Omdia, Next-generation Offensive Security Strategies Give Defenders the AI Advantage, May 2026. Importance of agentic AI to bolstering offensive security posture in the next 24 months. Results are not an endorsement of Cobalt. Any reliance on these results is at the third party’s own risk.

2. Source – Omdia, Next-generation Offensive Security Strategies Give Defenders the AI Advantage, May 2026. Current level of autonomy of the AI agents used for offensive security tasks. Results are not an endorsement of Cobalt. Any reliance on these results is at the third party’s own risk.

Omdia disclaimer

The Omdia research, data and information referenced herein (the “Omdia Materials”) are the copyrighted property of TechTarget, Inc. and its subsidiaries or affiliates (together “Informa TechTarget”) or its third-party data providers and represent data, research, opinions, or viewpoints published by Informa TechTarget, and are not representations of fact.

The Omdia Materials reflect information and opinions from the original publication date and not from the date of this document. The information and opinions expressed in the Omdia Materials are subject to change without notice and Informa TechTarget does not have any duty or responsibility to update the Omdia Materials or this publication as a result.

Omdia Materials are delivered on an “as-is” and “as-available” basis. No representation or warranty, express or implied, is made as to the fairness, accuracy, completeness, or correctness of the information, opinions, and conclusions contained in Omdia Materials.

To the maximum extent permitted by law, Informa TechTarget and its affiliates, officers, directors, employees, agents, and third-party data providers disclaim any liability (including, without limitation, any liability arising from fault or negligence) as to the accuracy or completeness or use of the Omdia Materials. Informa TechTarget will not, under any circumstance whatsoever, be liable for any trading, investment, commercial, or other decisions based on or made in reliance of the Omdia Materials.